Hobbs College presents honors theses

By Kedrick Nettleton, Faith Editor

As the school year rapidly comes to a close over the next few weeks, the hard work and dedication of honors students across the campus is coming to fruition.

Students from different disciplines across campus are presenting their honors theses at various afternoons in the months of April and May, and many of these presentations include the final projects from students in the Hobbs College of Theology and Ministry.

Chandler Warren presented his final thesis on April 15.

His project, titled “The God of Hell: The Relationship Between the Divine and The Damned,” was concerned with the doctrine of a literal hell, and how God’s inherent attributes interact and in-form on that doctrine.

Warren’s research ranged from a number of aspects, the most interesting aspect being the relation of God to time.

“Chandler’s thesis presentation is a model for OBU Honors students, whether in Hobbs or some other discipline,” Dickinson Associate Professor of Religion and the faculty advisor for Warren’s thesis Matthew Emerson said.

“His argument is sophisticated, his methodology is careful, and his presentation was both witty and informative.”

Other presentations from students in the department included Jonathan Knox, who brought forth his project titled “The Nature of Sin: Inward, Outward, Ultimate,” April 22.

In the future, there are three more presentations dealing with subjects relating to religion.

Matthew Shively will present “Predestination, Election, and Encouragement to Christlike-ness in Paul’s Epistles” Thursday, May 2.

John Ellis’ thesis – “What has Darwin to do with Design? Are Evolution and Christianity Compatible?” – will be presented Tuesday, May 7.

Noah Jones will finish off the honors presentation Wednesday May 8, with his thesis, “The Mereology of God Incarnate: A Critique of Part-Whole Approaches to Christ’s Attributes.”

Jones says that the title of his project sounds more complicated than it really is.

“I explore ways to understand traditional Christian beliefs about Jesus,” Jones said. “For example, I explore and critique some answers to questions like ‘If Jesus was fully God and fully man, was He material or immaterial?’ I also discuss similar questions related to Jesus’ omniscience and whether He was inside or outside time.”

For Jones, completing this thesis project was taxing.

“[It] was very difficult,” he said. “My thesis required more work by far than any other task I’ve had at OBU.”

That challenge, though, made the process memorable.

“It was especially rewarding to me to focus in so much detail on a single topic and become an expert (as much as is possible for an undergraduate) on some small thing,” Jones said.

All theses presentations take place in the Tulsa Royalties Auditorium in Bailey Business Center, and all presentations are open to the public.

Honors thesis leads to new math discovery

By Loren Rhoades, Assistant News Editor

Senior math major Kelsi Guleserian uncovered a mathematical theorem with the help of assistant professor of mathematics Dr. Cherith Tucker.

The two came up with the theorem while researching topics for Guleserian’s honors thesis.

“I knew I wanted to write a thesis because I wanted to study math more in-depth than what we would in class,” Guleserian said.

The process began with Guleserian’s interest in knot theory, which led them to the topic of the linking of circles.

Eventually, they put their focus on the linking of circles in the three-sphere.

The three-sphere is a sphere that lives in four-dimensional space, unlike the normal sphere which lives in three-dimensional space.

“It’s hard to visualize, because we only have three dimensions at our disposal,” Tucker said.

There are circles in the three-sphere that can be linked together where one passes through the other, or they can be separate from each other.

“We started looking at circles in the three-sphere at how we can tell if circles are linked or not linked,” Tucker said. “It led us to a result that applies in any dimension.”

From then on, they started to work with circles not only in the three-sphere but also in the higher spheres and dimensions.

After getting into the higher dimensions, they started studying the linking of spheres.

“When you go up further dimensions, they can be linked somehow where one passes through the center of the other, but they don’t actually intersect in any way,” Tucker said.

After thoroughly studying the linking of spheres in different dimensions, they came up with a result that can help them to answer questions about how other things are linked together.

For example, they have been looking at Borromean rings, which is another interesting way that things are linked.

Altogether the process of this discovery took about a month to a month and a half.

Now Gulseserian is in the process of finishing her thesis that covers this foundational theorem, in the hopes of having it approved and published. The thesis will cover the history of links and convexity, higher dimensions and their properties and any definitions or already proven theorems that are necessary to prove the theorem they have come up with.

“I’m wanting to make this more accessible by telling a story, the history of it, how it came to be and what you can apply it to,” Guleserian said.

Guleserian and Tucker submitted the first draft of the thesis to the honors board subcommittee at OBU this semester and got it approved.

Now they are going forward with different corollaries, as well as different points they can continue to prove with the theorem.

“I was surprised that we were able to prove something new in math,” Guleserian said, “that’s really cool to me.”

Guleserian and Tucker already have a couple questions they have easily proven and answered since being approved by the board.

They will continue this process until the thesis is complete.

From there the thesis will be resubmitted to the board and an outside reader will look over all the information.

Guleserian said doing this research is helping her to solidify what she hopes to do as part of her profession in the future.

Just knowing she could do the research required for the thesis has put her at ease.

“I’ve always known I wanted to be a professor of mathematics,” Guleserian said. “So having the research for this theorem under my belt is nice and comforting.”

Both Guleserian and Tucker are content with the results they continue to find and are leaving room for the possibility of even more discoveries.

“Kelsi has worked very hard on this, and I am very happy with the interesting result we have come up with,” Tucker said. “I am excited to see where it might lead and what other sorts of results we could get as corollaries to this theorem.”

Students conquer honors thesis projects

By Jonathan Soder, Features Editor

Come fall semester of junior year, students, particularly honors students, are at the point where they must decide whether or not to write a senior thesis.

For those who do, the process will span the last three semesters of their college career and involve extensive research into a specified topic within the student’s major.

While a daunting task for most, the road to a thesis project is well-mapped and traveled by many former and current thesis writers here at OBU.

One of these travelers is associate professor of philosophy and director of the honor program Dr. Tawa An-derson.

A two-time thesis writer himself, first for his undergraduate and second for his Ph.D., Anderson now oversees the thesis writing process for the honors program as head of the Honors committee.

His responsibilities include reviewing and approving thesis proposals in conjunction with the faculty advisor whom the student has chosen to study under.

As an unofficial part of his job, Anderson offers students advice about choosing their faculty advisor.

“Be diligent and regular in meeting with your faculty advisor,” Anderson said.

Anderson said that choosing correctly in the first place involves specific considerations for both the student and the faculty advisor.

“Choose your faculty mentor carefully,” Anderson said. “Ensure that it’s somebody who you really do want to work with because you’re stuck with them for the duration. And, ensure that it’s somebody you know has the time and ability to shepherd you through this process.”

This is advice for any student who wants to complete a senior thesis, not just those in the honors program.

Faculty advisors serve as editors and guides through the process of the contracted study, which is a semester of research that typically happens during the spring semester of junior year.

Research varies widely depending on the student’s major and proposed topic.

Senior math education major Hannah Durkee is writing her thesis over the merits of teaching formal mathematics instead of applied mathematics in primary and secondary education.

During her contracted study, she had to resort to research methods which are less common for most thesis writers.

“There wasn’t a lot of literature, or studies that had been done previously, so I didn’t have that to pull from,” Durkee said, “I decided to do my own survey and interviews and things like that.”

Durkee sent out an email to every person listed on Oklahoma’s Department of Education website as a secondary math teacher, over 3,000 emails in total. Of that total, 169 teachers replied.

Durkee said one of her favorite parts of this process has been reading the suggestions teachers gave in response to several of the questions included on the survey.

“One of them was like, ‘If you could change the state standards, would you. If so, how?’,” Durkee said. “Some of those were really good responses because there’s a lot of people who are, obviously, very passionate about state standards and standardized testing and things like that.”

Durkee also received practical advice as a result of the survey without intentionally seeking it out.

“I just got tons of really good ideas to use with my future classes, which was really cool to be able to read those responses,” Durkee said. “That’s the part of the research that I enjoy the most, seeing things that actually help me and are directly applicable to the things I want to do.”

The enjoyment in learning Durkee expressed is one of the hopes Anderson and the honors program as a whole express for thesis writers.

Another portion of Anderson’s job is a joint effort with the rest of the Honors committee members to guide, review, critique and encourage students throughout the thesis writing process.

“The spirit [of the committee] is one of sharpening,” Anderson said. “The biggest blessing from being on the Honors Committee is that we get to learn an incredible amount by reading through all of these thesis projects each year… We need to approach it with a spirit of openness and teachability.”

The spirit of the committee is two-fold though, just as the analogy in scripture of brothers sharpening one another as “iron sharpens iron.”

“The other spirit that we need to have is one of constructive criticism…” Anderson said. “Although we may not be experts in the discipline or the area that the student is writing, we’re nonetheless intelligent enough that we can follow the research, we can follow the line of argumentation and we can become familiar with the material, familiar enough we’re able to give meaningful input.”

Critiques come primarily from the student’s continual contact with his/her faculty advisor and two progress report meetings with the Honors Committee – one in the fall semester and one in early spring.

Students also send their paper to a reader outside of OBU to have it critiqued after both progress reports have occurred.

Receiving criticism is one of the aspects of thesis writing that Anderson said students consistently struggle with.

Often students misinterpret the suggestions the committee is making for them or are frustrated by the need to return and expand on a project that has already taken nine months of their time.

His tips for dealing with this? Be teachable. Just as the Honors Committee is learning from a student’s research, so too should the student be willing to continue learning about their topic and how to properly explain it even after the bulk of research and writing is over.

As mentioned previously, thesis writing isn’t exclusively for honors students. Assistant professor of mathematics Dr. Cherith Tucker is working on the Honors Committee as well as advising a non-Honors thesis for senior math Kelsi Guleserian.

“I have been incredibly proud of Kelsi Guleserian this semester,” Tucker said. “Our research has taken many unexpected turns and we’ve been stuck many times, but she has had a great attitude and a passion for our work throughout the entire process.”

At this point in the semester, Durkee is approximately a third of the way through her estimated 60-page paper. On October 25, she will meet with members of the Honors Committee like Anderson and Tucker for her fall progress report.

Once that’s done, she’ll continue writing in preparation for her spring progress report, all the while guided by Anderson, committee members and her advisor, Dr. Sarah Marsh.

For any underclassmen interested in writing a senior thesis, Tucker suggests talking to professors before junior year to make sure they are capable and willing to advise.

On top of this, reading articles inside of one’s field of study is a good way for students to begin narrowing their topic even before submitting a proposal.